Collector’s Closet

Shoes for sale for your permanent collection.

Shop now

Items: 80

Filter
  • Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Horsebit Black Leather Boots
    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Horsebit Black Leather Boots
    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Horsebit Black Leather Boots
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Horsebit Black Leather Boots

    FITS SIZE US 5 TO 5.5
    $1,170
  • Roberto Cavalli SS 2003 Chinoiserie Red Satin Boots
    Roberto Cavalli SS 2003 Chinoiserie Red Satin Boots
    Roberto Cavalli SS 2003 Chinoiserie Red Satin Boots
    For purchase

    Roberto Cavalli SS 2003 Chinoiserie Red Satin Boots

    FITS SIZE US 5 TO 5.5
    $3,770
  • Dolce & Gabbana 2000s Denim Snakeskin Boots
    Dolce & Gabbana 2000s Denim Snakeskin Boots
    Dolce & Gabbana 2000s Denim Snakeskin Boots
    For purchase

    Dolce & Gabbana 2000s Denim Snakeskin Boots

    FITS SIZE US 6 TO 6.5
    $1,305
  • Christian Dior by Galliano SS 2004 Black Studded Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano SS 2004 Black Studded Boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano SS 2004 Black Studded Boots

    FITS SIZE US 7.5
    $1,270
  • Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Leopard "I Love Dior" Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Leopard "I Love Dior" Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Leopard "I Love Dior" Ankle Boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Leopard "I Love Dior" Ankle Boots

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $900
  • Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 Black Gambler Ankle Boots

    FITS SIZE US 6.5
    $1,250
  • casadei 2000s cowprint boots
    casadei 2000s cowprint boots
    casadei 2000s cowprint boots
    For purchase

    Casadei 2000s Cowprint Boots

    FITS SIZE US 6.5 TO 7
    $545
  • Christian Dior by Galliano 2000s Black Leather Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano 2000s Black Leather Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano 2000s Black Leather Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior by Galliano 2000s Black Leather Ankle Boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano 2000s Black Leather Ankle Boots

    FITS SIZE US 7
    $935
  • gucci by tom ford fw 1999 caramel horsebit boots
    gucci by tom ford fw 1999 caramel horsebit boots
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Caramel Horsebit Boots

    FITS SIZE US 6
    $870
  • christian dior 2000s brown suede boots
    christian dior 2000s brown suede boots
    christian dior 2000s brown suede boots
    christian dior 2000s brown suede boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Brown Suede Boots

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $550
  • roberto cavalli ss 2002 denim leopard laser cut boots
    roberto cavalli ss 2002 denim leopard laser cut boots
    For purchase

    Roberto Cavalli SS 2002 Denim & Leopard Laser Cut Boots

    FITS SIZE US 7
    $705
  • Christian Dior 2000s Black Fur Suede Ankle Boots
    Christian Dior 2000s Black Fur Suede Ankle Boots
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Black Fur Suede Ankle Boots

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $470
Shop featured
  • Gucci by Tom Ford FW 2003 Horsebit Mules
    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 2003 Horsebit Mules
    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 2003 Horsebit Mules
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 2003 Horsebit Mules

    FITS SIZE US 9
    $785
  • Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2003 Bondage Heels
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2003 Bondage Heels
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2003 Bondage Heels

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $595
  • Dolce & Gabbana Ponyhair Slingback Pumps
    Dolce & Gabbana Ponyhair Slingback Pumps
    Dolce & Gabbana Ponyhair Slingback Pumps
    For purchase

    Dolce & Gabbana Ponyhair Slingback Pumps

    FITS SIZE US 5 TO 5.5
    $615
  • Chanel 2004 Grey & Bone Pink Slingback Pumps
    Chanel 2004 Grey & Bone Pink Slingback Pumps
    Chanel 2004 Grey & Bone Pink Slingback Pumps
    For purchase

    Chanel 2004 Grey & Bone Pink Slingback Pumps

    FITS SIZE US 8 TO 8.5
    $815
  • Gucci by Tom Ford 2002 Heart Cut Out Heels
    Gucci by Tom Ford 2002 Heart Cut Out Heels
    Gucci by Tom Ford 2002 Heart Cut Out Heels
    Gucci by Tom Ford 2002 Heart Cut Out Heels
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford 2002 Heart Cut Out Heels

    FITS SIZE US 5.5
    $1,170
  • Prada FW 1999 Grey Sequin Heels
    Prada FW 1999 Grey Sequin Heels
    For purchase

    Prada FW 1999 Grey Sequin Heels

    FITS SIZE US 5 TO 5.5
    $595
  • Christian Dior 2000s Light Blue Satin Heels
    Christian Dior 2000s Light Blue Satin Heels
    Christian Dior 2000s Light Blue Satin Heels
    Christian Dior 2000s Light Blue Satin Heels
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Light Blue Satin Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6.5 TO 7
    $415
  • Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Pumps
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford FW 1999 Pumps

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $485
  • Prada 2004 Black Floral Heels
    Prada 2004 Black Floral Heels
    Prada 2004 Black Floral Heels
    For purchase

    Prada 2004 Black Floral Heels

    FITS SIZE US 8.5 TO 9
    $445
  • Manolo Blahnik 2000s "Campari" Mary Jane Heels
    Manolo Blahnik 2000s "Campari" Mary Jane Heels
    Manolo Blahnik 2000s "Campari" Mary Jane Heels
    Manolo Blahnik 2000s "Campari" Mary Jane Heels
    For purchase

    Manolo Blahnik 2000s "Campari" Mary Jane Heels

    FITS SIZE US 7
    $745
  • jimmy choo 2000s nude python sandals
    jimmy choo 2000s nude python sandals
    jimmy choo 2000s nude python sandals
    For purchase

    Jimmy Choo 2000s Nude Python Sandals

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $670
  • Gucci by Tom Ford 2000s Suede Heels
    Gucci by Tom Ford 2000s Suede Heels
    Gucci by Tom Ford 2000s Suede Heels
    For purchase

    Gucci by Tom Ford 2000s Suede Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6.5 TO 7
    $250
Collector's Closet Collector's Closet
Shop featured
  • chanel ss 1995 mustard logo sandals
    chanel ss 1995 mustard logo sandals
    chanel ss 1995 mustard logo sandals
    For purchase

    Chanel SS 1995 Mustard Logo Sandals

    FITS SIZE US 6.5
    $500
  • jimmy choo 2000s suede jeweled sandal heels
    jimmy choo 2000s suede jeweled sandal heels
    For purchase

    Jimmy Choo 2000s Suede Jeweled Sandal Heels

    FITS SIZE US 8
    $695
  • chanel 2000s black bondage heels
    chanel 2000s black bondage heels
    chanel 2000s black bondage heels
    For purchase

    Chanel 2000s Black Bondage Heels

    FITS SIZE US 4.5 TO 5
    $815
  • christian dior 2000s leopard heels
    christian dior 2000s leopard heels
    christian dior 2000s leopard heels
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Leopard Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6.5
    $745
  • Christian Dior 2000s Black Kitten Heels
    Christian Dior 2000s Black Kitten Heels
    Christian Dior 2000s Black Kitten Heels
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Black Kitten Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6.5
    $565
  • Gucci 2000s Monogram Teal Horsebit Mules
    Gucci 2000s Monogram Teal Horsebit Mules
    For purchase

    Gucci 2000s Monogram Teal Horsebit Mules

    FITS SIZE US 8 TO 8.5
    $620
  • d g 2000s gold strappy heels
    d g 2000s gold strappy heels
    d g 2000s gold strappy heels
    d g 2000s gold strappy heels
    For purchase

    Dolce & Gabbana D&G 2000s Gold Strappy Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6
    $715
  • Chanel 2000s White Slingback Heels
    Chanel 2000s White Slingback Heels
    Chanel 2000s White Slingback Heels
    For purchase

    Chanel 2000s White Slingback Heels

    FITS SIZE US 7 TO 7.5
    $715
  • Prada 2000s Black Satin Floral Heels
    Prada 2000s Black Satin Floral Heels
    Prada 2000s Black Satin Floral Heels
    For purchase

    Prada 2000s Black Satin Floral Heels

    FITS SIZE US 5.5
    $350
  • Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 “I Love Dior” Leopard Pumps
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 “I Love Dior” Leopard Pumps
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 “I Love Dior” Leopard Pumps
    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 “I Love Dior” Leopard Pumps
    For purchase

    Christian Dior by Galliano FW 2004 “I Love Dior” Leopard Pumps

    FITS SIZE US 7
    $895
  • christian dior 2000s gray denim heels
    christian dior 2000s gray denim heels
    christian dior 2000s gray denim heels
    christian dior 2000s gray denim heels
    For purchase

    Christian Dior 2000s Gray Denim Heels

    FITS SIZE US 6.5 TO 7
    $615
  • yves saint laurent 2000s platform
    yves saint laurent 2000s platform
    yves saint laurent 2000s platform
    For purchase

    Yves Saint Laurent 2000s Platform Mules

    FITS SIZE US 7.5
    $425

A few things to know.

What condition are items in?

All Collector's Closet pieces are pre-owned vintage rated on a condition scale from Fair to Like New. Condition details are transparently displayed on each product page.

How does sizing work?

We provide the marked size as well as the US shoe size equivalent for every shoe since vintage sizing varies from contemporary size guides.

How does Shipping & Returns work?

All shoes are shipped in 2-7 business days depending on your location within the United States. For rush shipping, please reach out at hello@isleofmondaynyc.com. Given they are vintage, all shoes are final sale. Please read the condition of each item carefully and contact your local cobbler for future upkeep.

Why can’t I rent these?

Collector's Closet is a special curation of vintage pieces available only to buy and own permanently, safeguarding their preservation. We currently carry shoes and are excited to add retired rentals in the future.